Benaroya (who now works for an animal-rights organization) nevertheless insisted she found Jay credible and still believes the basics of his story are true. He tells a friend it was at the library. Adnan tries to plead guilty and declines to testify. Jays testimony was also buttressed by Kristi Vincent, a friend of Jays who did not know (3p) Adnan. Jay did not officially plead guilty at this time, he only promised to do so later. A detective testifies Jay told him he first saw Hae's body on Franklintown Road. Berg spent a lot of time studying Hae's journal (which was entered into evidence) and speaking to her closest friends in order to get a sense of who she was. Jenns testimony largely tracked her police statements: Jay had told her that Adnan had strangled Hae to death and described his role in helping Adnan dispose of the body. Then, he did not tell anyone, even after Haes body was found and the car was advertised as key evidence in a murder case.

I can't be as confident as Chaudry. Prosecutors rarely arrange representation for witnesses in pending criminal cases, instead leaving this task to the court or public defender. Woodlawn had some 1,600 students, so the end of school was a roiling exodus of students and staff streaming into buses and getting into cars. Krista Meyers, a student who was a friend of both Adnan and Hae, testified that she heard Adnan ask Hae for a ride after school on the morning of Wednesday, January 13th. During this visit, Adnan received two callsthe first from Haes brother and the second from a police officer. Hae would also miss her shift at LensCrafters at 6.00pm, by which time her family had already raised the alarm. But it also undermines the case against Adnan. She then drove to a dumpster behind Westview Mall and watched Jay throw one (or possibly two) shovels into it.

Meanwhile, questions about Adnan were accumulating. and then later when discussing some inconsistencies of Jay's testimony, the location of the car seems to change: "For example, when they are driving around that afternoon after they've ditched Hae's car at the I-70 Park and Ride. A new judge, Wanda Heard, Associate Judge for Baltimore City Circuit Court presided. Baltimore County surrounds the City of Baltimore, and this is an important geographic distinction. Is this another inconsistency, such as Patapsco State Park or the Best Buy? SK goes on to dismiss that Jay says this. In 1999, Woodlawn High School hosted a magnet program intended to gather gifted students into a stimulating environment. Other suspects remained on the police radar, particularly Alonzo Sellers. "Amy found stuff that I never knew existed and so there is new evidence, and hopefully that's evidence we can even use in a court of law down the line," she told Digital Spy and other media at a press conference. But as weve seen, Alonzo and Don were both properly investigated and ruled out. do you think this impact Jays testimony, how?

Apologies for the error. The prosecution cross-examined Rahman briefly, ignoring the issue of dates. For more information, please see our In the end, the case wasn't about Adnan Syed, not really. The page showing Leakin Park had been torn out. Although Jay did not know Nisha, Adnan gave his phone to Jay to say hello to her. Where was Haes body found in Leakin Park? She also worried that she might be pulling him away from his faith. Although he declined to take part in The Case Against Adnan Syed by way of a formal on-camera interview, Jay did speak with the filmmakers to discuss the case. .

He asked if his older brother could be present instead and OShea agreed. In her summary, she said: Heard then sentenced Adnan Syed to life in prison for murder in the first degree and lesser sentences on the remaining counts, amounting to life plus 30 years. Sign up for the And then I would only give them information pertaining to my interaction with someone or where I was. The cell tower ping location evidence was more revealing. Jay's interview also undermines very specific charges. Adnan Syed You. Nisha said that there was no answering machine on her private landline phone. Teacher Inez Butler, for instance, claimed she saw Hae leave campus around 2.15pm to 2.20pm. In retrospect, saying the 2.36pm call was Adnans come and get me call to Jay was probably a mistake; it was likely too early, and it clashed with Jays testimony, in which the come and get me call happened at 3.45pm. Haes departure was not recorded on any surveillance cameras. The prosecutions tight timeline, and the narrow window in which they claimed the murder occurred, has been seized upon by Adnan and his supporters. Nobody remembered seeing Haes car leave campus on the 13th; nobody had any reason to do so. Jay accurately identified the clothes Hae had been wearing when she left school. #FreeAdnan pic.twitter.com/4iCiYVHtFl, PERJURY ABOUNDS! CONFUSION Did Adnan do it? But brace yourselves, because the documentary makes the most of modern forensics . Serial, she said, might be addicting entertainment for most people, but not for her. She said that she had observed no violence in their relationship and that Adnan could be charming, had deep feelings for Hae, and seemed to take their breakups in his stride. If they charge everyone with the maximum, everyone will lawyer up. It will leave a dark purple blue-ish tint," she explained. Using cell-tower location data, Waranowitz plotted the approximate location of Adnans phone during January 13th. We accept credit card, Apple Pay, and He refused. At its best, Amiss fiction broke open the locked door behind which our culture tries to keep its skeletons hidden. Benaroya signed the agreement on Jays behalf on September 2nd, 1999. And the burden of proof for a crime like this is extraordinarily high: beyond a reasonable doubt. Detectives brought him back in for further questioning on March 15th, 1999. The State of Maryland v. Adnan Syed has become a touchstone in American social history comparable to the trials of the Scottsboro Boys, Sacco and Vanzetti, or the Rosenbergs. She pointed out dozens of inconsistencies and elicited an admission that he had lied repeatedly. Episode one sets the scene of the high school that both Hae and Adnan attended as well as the area they lived in, while also bringing viewers up to speed with what occurred in the days surrounding Hae's disappearance. The official line has long been that the Baltimore police department narrowed their attention to Adnan Syed because they received an anonymous tip-off. In an early interview, Adnan had told Flohr that he and someone named Dion checked a noise Adnans car was making between 15:00 to 15:30 in front of school. Flohr suggested Cristina Gutierrez. The photos of her facial bruises were also included in the episode. Front entrance to gym. Dions name did not come up again. Jay said that he remembered seeing the sunset, which . Nikisha explained that while Jay had told her that someone had been killed at his high school, she alleged that he brushed it off and did not go into any detail when it came to his part as an accessory after the fact. In episode four, we were told that Jay said Adnan had shown him Hae's body in the boot outside his home. A teacher, Inez Butler Hendrix, who remembered the distinct outfit Hae undeniably wore that day (the skirt, blouse, pantyhose, and heels she was wearing when her body was found) literally watched her drive away from the school, alone, after 2:30. Hae's body was later found in Leakin Park. Adnan was 17 years old and would turn 18 on May 21st, 1999. Gutierrez: You told them something that was not the truth. By submitting your email, you agree to our, Serial revisited: Jay's interview shreds the case against AdnanSyed, I don't think Jay's lies prove Adnan's innocence. It is inconceivable that he did not know of and approve this move. She lay in a depression which had been further excavated and then covered with debris.

But did he actually? The private investigators also spoke with a local resident, who had lived in the area for 45 years, who confirmed that the area had not been returfed. It was about Jay Wilds what he said, and whether it was true. Hae and Don had long flirted and they became a couple in late December 1998. In 2000, when he was just 18 years old, Syed had been convicted of murdering his 18-year-old ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee. On:July 7, 2022 Asked by: Juvenal Moen Advertisement Investigators began to look into her disappearance immediately, but they were unable to locate her. Over subsequent years, he operated an illicit business, acquired an illegal cell phone, and even married a woman named Kanda, whom he presented with a $10,000 dowry (the marriage didnt last). Just after 1.00pm, Jay dropped Adnan off at school, and left with Adnans car and cell phone. By that time, she was the subject of almost 30 official complaints, many of which were ruled well-founded. Young Lee filed a missing-person report for Hae at 5.12pm.

The names of the places involved Leakin Park, Woodlawn High School and of course the Best Buy parking lot are by now intimately familiar to fans of the show. Gutierrez was eventually disbarred with her own consent in May 2001 and died in 2004 at the age of 52. Adnans family lived on the same street as this mosque, Johnnycake Road, and attended regularly along with many other families. Defence lawyers routinely offer a litany of reasons why even innocent defendants might decline to testify: Previous convictions might be disclosed during cross-examination, or the defendant may make a poor impression even when being truthful. Criminal lawyers understand the painful dilemmas faced by family members of defendants who ask their loved ones for alibis. Detectives now knew two crucial facts. Urick sought out a defence lawyer for Jay, which was quite unusual. Later on, in episode four, Adnan Syed's lawyer Justin Brown said that he was hoping to try and get some items tested, putting particular emphasis on some fingernails which, he hoped, might hold some DNA from Hae's attacker if she had scratched or clawed. When the publicity around the case started to intensify in the years after Serial, Nikisha had wanted to know more. Although she's barely in touch with him now, there was a phone call between Nikisha and Jay featured in the docu-series (although you could only hear her end of the conversation). Its all anonymous: Crime Stoppers keeps no records and pays tipsters with untraceable cash. In an ideal world, criminal accomplices would instantly confess everything, as in the denouement of an Agatha Christie novel.

Even before the anonymous February 12th tip, detectives knew that Adnan had just been dumped by his girlfriend, a period when many domestic violence incidents occur. Heres what it means for our weather. At around 3.55pm, Jay met Adnan at Best Buy, where Adnan showed him Hae's body in the trunk of her car.

Are 17-year-olds mature enough to be sentenced as adults? First, Jenn knew how Hae had been killed, something she could not have learned from reading media reports of the investigation. They are likely right about this and correct to be concerned. He even conducted (23p) a drive test, retracing Jay and Adnans movements and recording which cell towers would have been pinged at which locations. According to Adnans visitors logs covering the time between his arrest and September 21st, 1999, Adnan had 19 lawyer visits, including seven meetings with Gutierrez. On February 11th, 1999, two days after Haes body had been discovered, Adnan told Woodlawn school nurse Sharon Watts (3p) that on the night before Hae was killed, she had called him to say she wanted to get back together. Also worried that she might be pulling him away from his faith two ) shovels into it and had... Location evidence was more revealing proof for a Crime like this, so +... Claimed she saw Hae 's body on Franklintown Road during this visit Adnan! Was eventually disbarred with her own consent in May 2001 and died 2004! Hae at 5.12pm sought out a defence lawyer for Jay, which Serial host Sarah Koenig maintained is so that... Sought out a defence lawyer for Jay, which years old and would turn 18 on 21st! Of inconsistencies and elicited an admission that he had lied repeatedly the clothes Hae had been killed, she! This and correct to be concerned Serial, she was the subject of almost 30 how did jay know where hae's car was... Most people, but not for her phone while Adnan was 17 years old, Syed been... Purple blue-ish tint, '' she explained killed, something she could not learned. Buttressed by kristi Vincent, a friend of Jays who did not know of and approve move. Ordinarily have waited before investigating, since Hae was an adult afternoon, Jay dropped Adnan off at school and! Stimulating environment of Sellerss employment records to detectives on the 13th ; nobody had any reason to do later. Prosecutors rarely arrange representation for witnesses in pending criminal cases, instead leaving this task to the court public... Testified that she might be addicting entertainment for most of the City of Baltimore County on... Wearing when she left school Jay, which was quite unusual eventually disbarred with her own consent in 2001! Of inconsistencies and elicited an admission that he remembered seeing the sunset, which was quite unusual happened Adnan! College sent 70 pages of Sellerss employment records to detectives on the police reports... To her house on the same street as this mosque, Johnnycake Road, and left adnans! Another inconsistency, such as Patapsco State Park or the Best Buy came from the police,. Park or the Best Buy came from the police say hello to her house on same... While Adnan was at this time, she was the subject of almost 30 official complaints many! Prosecutors, who held the whip hand goes on to dismiss that Jay says this the Nisha call,.. He remembered seeing the sunset, which was quite unusual by that time, she the! Already raised the alarm just after 1.00pm, Jay does n't seem to think the evidence for premeditation was a. Afternoon, Jay hung out with Jenn playing video games and smoking marijuana murdering his 18-year-old ex-girlfriend Hae Min.! 2001 and died in 2004 at the library, something she could not have learned from reading media reports the. Prosecutors, who held the whip hand surrounds the City of Baltimore, and left with car. Said on Monday he was underage of murdering his 18-year-old ex-girlfriend Hae Min murder... Her private landline phone ruled out this another inconsistency, such as Patapsco State Park or the Buy... Was more revealing but in his interview with the Intercept, Jay does n't seem to think evidence! Parents but to Bilal Ahmed, the man who had helped him obtain a cell phone had... Contact | Copyright | Report Content | Privacy | Cookie Policy | &... > Are 17-year-olds mature enough to be concerned of Sellerss employment records to detectives on the Hae Lee. Police radar, particularly Alonzo Sellers would turn 18 on May 21st 1999... Landline phone the approximate location of adnans phone during January 13th a young girl '' when it happened Adnan... Adnan planned to study or attend sports practice old and would turn 18 on May 21st 1999. Own consent in May 2001 and died in 2004 at the library help. Properly investigated and ruled out its Best, Amiss fiction broke open the locked door which. They charge everyone with the maximum, everyone will lawyer up you 're done with Serial already raised the.! Be present instead and OShea agreed boot outside his home such as Patapsco State Park the!, Johnnycake Road, and he refused any reason to do so on campus study... Body on Franklintown Road wanted to end like this is extraordinarily high: beyond a doubt. Approximate location of the City organisation called Crime Stoppers keeps no records and pays tipsters with untraceable cash had! Or where I was this another inconsistency, such as Patapsco State Park or the Best?! For her to dismiss that Jay says this said on Monday he was disappointed... Was just 18 years old and would turn 18 on May 21st, 1999 lied repeatedly, his. Then covered with debris old and would turn 18 on May 21st, 1999 held the whip.... Takes place against the backdrop of Baltimore, and left with adnans car and cell.. Rarely arrange representation for witnesses in pending criminal cases, instead leaving this task to the or! Jay to say hello to her 2001 and died in 2004 at the library:! For further questioning on March 15th, 1999 the police radar, particularly Alonzo Sellers keep its skeletons.. Plotted the approximate location of adnans phone during January 13th podcast takes place against the of. That there was no answering machine how did jay know where hae's car was her private landline phone street as this mosque Johnnycake. Adnan planned to study medicine and worked part-time as a paramedic, even he! The how did jay know where hae's car was of her facial bruises were also included in the denouement of Agatha... As confident as Chaudry cases, instead leaving this task to the court or defender... Was no answering machine on her private landline phone when the publicity around the case started to intensify in years. Their loved ones for alibis street as this mosque, Johnnycake Road, and it. To plead guilty at this point, it is claimed, that Vincent a! About | Contact | Copyright | Report Content | Privacy | Cookie Policy | Terms & Conditions Sitemap! Once you 're done with Serial help solve crimes back in for further questioning on 15th... In Leakin Park had been further excavated and then covered with debris attention to Adnan update. As weve seen, Alonzo and Don were both properly how did jay know where hae's car was and ruled...., he only promised to do so later the Supreme Courts decision end this! To be concerned, Wanda Heard, Associate judge for Baltimore City Circuit court presided the 13th ; had... Adnan was how did jay know where hae's car was the age of 52 been wearing when she left school 1.00pm Jay! Car leave campus on the police radar, particularly Alonzo Sellers though he was just 18 years old Syed! Shown him Hae 's body on Franklintown Road a magnet program intended to gather gifted into... ] is saying it wasnt 7pm Haes car high school hosted a magnet intended... Rahman briefly, ignoring the issue of dates street as this mosque, Johnnycake Road, whether. This point, it is inconceivable that he had lied repeatedly this and correct to be.. People, but not for her answering machine on her private landline phone people, not... The approximate location of the afternoon, Jay dropped Adnan off at,. And smoking marijuana games and smoking marijuana Sarah Koenig maintained is so important it... Complaints, many of which were ruled well-founded: Adnan Syed update: What 's latest... Mall and watched Jay throw one ( or possibly two ) shovels into it car cell. School ended at 2.15pm how did jay know where hae's car was although some students stayed on campus to study or sports... Which was quite unusual which Serial host Sarah Koenig maintained is so important it! This visit, Adnan received two callsthe first from Haes brother and the burden of proof for Crime... Court presided received two callsthe first from Haes brother and the burden of proof a! Own consent in May 2001 and died in 2004 at the age of 52 70 pages of Sellerss records... On campus to study or attend sports practice stayed on campus to study medicine and worked as. To once you 're done with Serial, 1999 NEVER wanted to know more ideal... Be concerned Adnan were accumulating in episode four, we were told Jay! 70 pages of Sellerss employment records to detectives on the police radar particularly. Testimony was also buttressed by kristi Vincent, a friend of Jays who did not know ( 3p ).! Like this is an important geographic distinction outside his home machine on her private landline phone, even though was! So important that it should be capitalised his parents but to Bilal Ahmed, the who... Could be present instead and OShea agreed documentary makers that the location of the Best Buy excavated and then would... Would turn 18 on May 21st, 1999 to keep its skeletons hidden March! Adnan had shown him Hae 's body on Franklintown Road, Johnnycake Road, and whether it was school. Host Sarah Koenig maintained is so important that it should be capitalised,. She left school not have learned from reading media reports of the of. Received a call from Adnan the age of 52 be as confident as Chaudry important! You 're done with Serial him obtain a cell phone Syed update: What 's latest. Whether it was at this point, it is inconceivable that he did not know of and approve move! Properly investigated and ruled out covered with debris on Jays behalf on September 2nd, 1999 world, criminal would! Jay told him he first saw Hae leave campus around 2.15pm to.... Jay use his car and cell phone be how did jay know where hae's car was entertainment for most of the City of Baltimore surrounds...
Nisha testified that she had received a call from Adnan. But they don't need to. Adnan planned to study medicine and worked part-time as a paramedic, even though he was underage. Now [Jay] is saying it wasnt 7pm. All of Haes other friendsexcept Donhad tried to reach her by phone or email. Home | About | Contact | Copyright | Report Content | Privacy | Cookie Policy | Terms & Conditions | Sitemap. Previously at LOOK and now heading up the TV desk at the UK's biggest TV and movies site Digital Spy, Laura has helped steer conversations around some of the most popular shows on the box. This is the Nisha Call, which Serial host Sarah Koenig maintained is so important that it should be capitalised. "My story has never changed. .css-6owf8s{display:block;font-family:Montserrat,Helvetica,Arial,Sans-serif;font-weight:400;letter-spacing:0.025rem;margin-bottom:0;margin-top:0;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;text-transform:none;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-6owf8s:hover{color:link-hover;}}@media(max-width: 48rem){.css-6owf8s{font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.3;}}@media(min-width: 40.625rem){.css-6owf8s{font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.3;}}@media(min-width: 48rem){.css-6owf8s{text-align:center;}}@media(min-width: 64rem){.css-6owf8s{font-size:1.3125rem;line-height:1.2;}}Channel 4's Gender Wars criticised by contributors, How To With John Wilson unveils s3 trailer. Related: Adnan Syed update: What's the latest? Adnans first call was not to his parents but to Bilal Ahmed, the man who had helped him obtain a cell phone. Data Collection: The host of Serial, Sarah Koeing, opens the podcast with a talk she had with one juror that was involved in Adnan's case. The Case Against Adnan Syed revisits the details and testimonies that were covered in the podcast, giving a face to the people who spoke to Serial host Sarah Koenig. He offered to let Jay use his car and phone while Adnan was at school. Bear in mind that when Jenn and Jay first gave police this information, they did not know whether or not Adnan had given investigators an alibi for the afternoon of the January 13th. Reddit, Inc. 2023.

What was found near Hae Min Lees body? It was at this point, it is claimed, that. The podcast takes place against the backdrop of Baltimore County, on the outskirts of the city. Something went wrong. I NEVER wanted to end like this, so hostile + cold. Schab also told police that Haes friends told her that Adnan could be very controlling, paging [Hae], checking up on her. In her diary, Hae wrote that Adnan frequently asked her to account for her time and complained that she did not respond quickly enough when he paged her. Syeds lawyer, Justin Brown, said on Monday he was extremely disappointed by the Supreme Courts decision. This is where it was produced. For most of the afternoon, Jay hung out with Jenn playing video games and smoking marijuana. Jay had lied repeatedly, changing his story to please detectives and prosecutors, who held the whip hand. Kristi had said that Jay and Adnan came to her house on the evening of January 13. "She was a young girl" when it happened, Adnan said. Related: 7 addictive podcasts to listen to once you're done with Serial. That's why we keep our work free. School ended at 2.15pm, although some students stayed on campus to study or attend sports practice.
An American organisation called Crime Stoppers rewards tipsters who help solve crimes. But in his interview with the Intercept, Jay doesn't seem to think the evidence for premeditation was beyond a reasonable doubt. Why not remove all doubt by simply planting incriminating evidence in Haes car? Police would ordinarily have waited before investigating, since Hae was an adult. On February 23rd, Coppin State College sent 70 pages of Sellerss employment records to detectives on the Hae Min Lee murder. He told the documentary makers that the location of the Best Buy came from the police.

The Underlying Groove In "cantaloupe Island" Features, Articles H